TY - JOUR
T1 - A refined calibration of the Na-Li geothermometer for pelitic lithologies before and after orogenic metamorphism
AU - Liu, Hou Chun
AU - Chen, Chao Chang
AU - Lu, Yi Chia
AU - Yang, Huai Jen
AU - Chen, Yan Hong
AU - Lu, Yu Feng
AU - Lin, In Tian
AU - Chang, Sung Ping
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2025 Elsevier Ltd
PY - 2025/12
Y1 - 2025/12
N2 - Orogenic belts, especially those with recent tectonic and magmatic activities, can host geothermal waters with energy potential, however, exploration remains limited. In such terrains, geothermometers provide a cost-effective method of estimating reservoir temperatures based on water chemistry. In general, silica and Na-K geothermometers are used; however, both have limitations in metapelitic lithologies. Silica methods are biased by dilution and evaporation, while Na-K methods are skewed by K-feldspar metamorphic transformation to illite. Hence, in this context, the low reactivity of Li in geothermal waters makes the Na-Li geothermometer a more robust proxy for estimating reservoir temperatures. We compiled global geothermal well data on hydrogeochemistry and temperature to assess how lithology and water sources influence the Na/Li ratios. A consistent temperature-Na/Li ratios relationship were noticed across metamorphic, sedimentary and non-basaltic igneous rocks, suggesting metamorphism has limited effect on altering water Na/Li ratios. This implies the Na-Li geothermometer is equally applicable in pelitic and metapelitic settings, and a refined calibration for (meta)pelitic reservoirs recharged by meteoric or saline waters is as follows: 1000/T = 0.51±0.02 × log(Na/Li) + 1.22±0.05 Geothermal waters from the Chingshui metapelitic geothermal field validate this calibration, showing deviations of < 5.6%. Applying this calibration to the pelitic reservoirs in southwestern Taiwan yields temperatures consistent with those estimated by the Na-K geothermometer, highlighting the robustness of the Na-Li geothermometer for pelitic settings. Moreover, the Na-Li geothermometer demonstrates consistent accuracy before and after orogenic metamorphism, rendering it more reliable for metamorphic lithologies than the Na-K approach.
AB - Orogenic belts, especially those with recent tectonic and magmatic activities, can host geothermal waters with energy potential, however, exploration remains limited. In such terrains, geothermometers provide a cost-effective method of estimating reservoir temperatures based on water chemistry. In general, silica and Na-K geothermometers are used; however, both have limitations in metapelitic lithologies. Silica methods are biased by dilution and evaporation, while Na-K methods are skewed by K-feldspar metamorphic transformation to illite. Hence, in this context, the low reactivity of Li in geothermal waters makes the Na-Li geothermometer a more robust proxy for estimating reservoir temperatures. We compiled global geothermal well data on hydrogeochemistry and temperature to assess how lithology and water sources influence the Na/Li ratios. A consistent temperature-Na/Li ratios relationship were noticed across metamorphic, sedimentary and non-basaltic igneous rocks, suggesting metamorphism has limited effect on altering water Na/Li ratios. This implies the Na-Li geothermometer is equally applicable in pelitic and metapelitic settings, and a refined calibration for (meta)pelitic reservoirs recharged by meteoric or saline waters is as follows: 1000/T = 0.51±0.02 × log(Na/Li) + 1.22±0.05 Geothermal waters from the Chingshui metapelitic geothermal field validate this calibration, showing deviations of < 5.6%. Applying this calibration to the pelitic reservoirs in southwestern Taiwan yields temperatures consistent with those estimated by the Na-K geothermometer, highlighting the robustness of the Na-Li geothermometer for pelitic settings. Moreover, the Na-Li geothermometer demonstrates consistent accuracy before and after orogenic metamorphism, rendering it more reliable for metamorphic lithologies than the Na-K approach.
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105014179473
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105014179473#tab=citedBy
U2 - 10.1016/j.geothermics.2025.103482
DO - 10.1016/j.geothermics.2025.103482
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:105014179473
SN - 0375-6505
VL - 133
JO - Geothermics
JF - Geothermics
M1 - 103482
ER -